Fire Burning

Return the Burn – The Argument For Fire Burning

In Issues And Advocacy by Kasey RahnLeave a Comment

Fire, in some dosage or another, is not only natural, but an essential component of almost every North American landscape, from the plains of Oklahoma to the West’s vast elk country. Historically, nearly all of it saw flames regularly—from southwestern ponderosa pine forests that burned every five to 20 years to northern mountains blanketed with lodgepole that torched dramatically once a century.

Fire acts to refresh the system—returning nutrients to the soil, stimulating plant growth, and restoring forest health and resiliency. Prescribed burns (aka controlled burns) seek to replicate the work wildfires have traditionally brought forth, but in a measured and calculated fashion. Ignited by highly trained fire managers under specific conditions, they’re a way to reap fire’s natural benefits while eliminating much of the uncertainty, risk and cost.

The biggest challenge with prescribed fire is the public’s perception of it.

“[People] see smoke, and they go to lighting up the phones, calling the fire department and everything. Fire is a natural part of the ecosystem. It is necessary. And done correctly, it is a good thing.”Jack Waymire, senior biologist ODWC

At the Pushmataha WMA, closed-canopy control plots, which are neither thinned nor burned, produce about 200 pounds of forage per acre. But treated savannah areas—thinned and then burned on two-year intervals—produce 4,000 pounds per acre.

Breeding bird surveys have also shown upticks in both the number and diversity of birds in the area, from bobwhite quail to Bachman’s sparrows.

Non-thinned/burned plots
Forage per Acre
Thinned & Burned Plots
Forage per Acre

What happens without burns?

Without flames, forest health nosedives. As flammable fuels build up, so does the likelihood for a catastrophic wildfire. In many circumstances, a lack of fire can create vast landscapes of homogenous forest—trees of the same species and age—which can leave forests vulnerable to largescale insect and disease outbreaks, like pine beetle infestations in lodgepole pine forests across the West.

Prescribed fire, on the other hand, provides an incredible nutrient flush. It safely reduces hazardous fuel build-ups while helping to control pests, diseases and invasive species. And it greatly improves habitat for everything from butterflies to bulls. From the elk hunter’s perspective, fires help to jumpstart grasses, forbs and browse, improving forage—and the health of the herd in the process.

This article was adapted from the March/April Bugle Magazine

Click to download the full article